It is another matter that God in His Mercy did not allow the story to end there! While God knows the future and has the power to change it, He cannot do so if man is to retain his personal volition. Why did God create the tree of knowledge of good and evil in the first place? (1999), Diccionario Expositivo de Palabras del Antiguo y Nuevo Testamento Exhaustivo (Colombia, Editorial Caribe. Favorite Answer. What is this crucial data that will throw light on this ghastly affair? Because the tree was located in the midst of the garden, there was no way that man could eat of its fruit by mistaking it for another. Why did God create the tree of the knowledge of good and evil? The tree itself was not “of good and evil”(i.e., that it did not contain good and evil). Why did God keep back just one thing from the people he made? And the Lord God commanded the man, saying, “Of every tree of the garden you may freely eat; but of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil you shall not eat, for in the day that you eat of it you shall surely die.”. To his utter discomfiture, Rand finds that this removal of the ability to choose between good and evil, has now transformed people into one dimensional beings — people who are happy not because they are happy but because there no longer is the choice to be sad, people who experience only positive emotions, because they have been robbed of the choice to experience a ‘negative’ emotion such as sadness, pain, suffering,etc. 1. Why would he make people in his image, then give them one prohibition? God knows everything. Go d ’s Cre atio n Gen 1:31 And God saw everything that He had made, and behold, it was very good. However, as noted earlier, God is love (1 John 4:8); and this trait of God, as exhibited in the tragic story of Eden, is shown in His providence for man. Fourth, God created many more trees, with the intent that man would not have need to eat of this prohibited tree (Genesis 2:9). The fact that this tree, too, was in the midst of the garden served as a means of attraction to do good when man was influenced to disobey God. Question: “Why did God put the tree of knowledge of good and evil in the Garden of Eden?” Answer: God put the tree of knowledge of good and evil in the Garden of Eden to give Adam and Eve a choice to obey Him or disobey Him. Why God Created the Tree of Knowledge of Good and Evil (The Forbidden Fruit)? The truthful and unavoidable conclusion, then, is that the tree of the knowledge of good and evil was in fact “very good.”. added). Nevertheless, when expressing discernment and/or intimate involvement, Moses used the term yada. And, by partaking of that knowledge, … The attraction of every tree in the garden represented a fundamental piece intended to distract any possible craving that man might have for the tree of the knowledge of good and evil. So by essentially placing the Tree of Knowledge of Good and Evil in the Garden of Eden and commanding Man to NOT eat from the tree, God was providing Man with the choices of good and evil. This is the greatest gift that Man received from God at the moment of his creation. In the context of today’s world, it difficult to live without coming face to face with suffering in one form or the other. We, as humans, act in a similar manner. But the act of taking the fruit and eating it was an act of rebellion. Why didn't he make humans perfect, so they would be wise enough to ignore the stupid tree? It was taking something made with God's character and acting contrary to … Third, the prohibition and potential punishment were intended to serve as a “fence” to prevent man from violating the divinely instituted boundary. God always wanted for man to keep His commands, and hence He used various means to facilitate such obedience. Even though by its very name this tree denoted something positive, man still would not have been excused if he had disobeyed a divine command not to eat its fruit.]. God, in His infinite love, wanted for man to enjoy free will, and to choose to do His will. Is he obsessed with loyalty? … I mean, if God didn’t want them to touch the tree, He could have kept them from it by any number of means. If God hadn’t placed the Tree of Knowledge of Good and Evil in the Garden of Eden in the first place, Adam and Eve wouldn’t have sinned and the world’s problems would be moot. I would venture that the question is asked out of man's perspective, not God's. On the other hand, there are those who do believe in the loving God the Bible reveals (1 John 4:8), but who find it difficult to understand (or explain): (a) why God allows some things to happen to His creatures without supernaturally intervening; and (b) why it even “appears” that sometimes God Himself influences things negatively, thereby bringing misfortune down on man. added). The purpose of this website is to promote critical thinking on the text of the Holy Bible, by Christians. And the evening and the morning were the sixth day. The woman, following the “shrewd example” of her mate who thought he had placed the guilt upon her, quickly pondered: “The serpent deceived me, and I ate” (Genesis 3:13). This location was strategic. Sinclair Ferguson addresses this in The Whole Christ. added). Out of the ground the LORD God caused to grow every tree that is pleasing to the sight and good for food; the tree of life also in the midst of the garden, and the tree of the knowledge of good and evil. In light of the above thought, it is not possible to lay blame on God for creating the Tree of Knowledge of Good and Evil. The Blame Game 4. It was disobedience of Adam and Eve, who had been told by God not to eat of the tree (Gen 2:17), that caused disorder in the creation, thus humanity inherited sin and guilt from Adam and Eve's sin. Relevance. God didn’t have slaves in mind when He created Man. Therefore, with this single defamatory charge, many men have attempted to forsake all weight of culpability and responsibility. Update: If he hadn't created it, wouldn't human kind have been perfect in the eyes of God? Since the earliest ages of human history, people have tried to excuse their wrong actions, and thereby avoid their personal responsibility. The first and most often considered purpose was to provide man with a choice: to love and serve God willingly or to rebel against him and reject the one prohibition he had given them. The problem isn't God, it's man. This shows how important the ability to choose between right and wrong is for us, because it is that line that separates us from being humans or mindless slaves — ‘robots’ in modern terminology. What was the purpose in that tricky Tree of the Knowledge of Good and Evil? In the middle of the garden were the tree of life and the tree of the knowledge of good and evil. Also, can good and evil even be that black and white? It is said that in the 20th century more people were killed than all previous other centuries combined, thanks to the World Wars, the Holocaust, systemic genocide, gulags and famines, earthquakes, diseases and so forth. In conclusion, one more point needs to be stressed. The blame falls solely on Man for rejecting and rebelling against God. As an example, we bring children into this world with the foreknowledge that they will get sick, make wrong choices, suffer, be hated, get old, get weak, and die. Faultless compassion: is it a realistic goal? What does this verse mean? There is only one thing that squeaks in our eardrum—something that has impeded many from believing in the Creator—the creation of a specific tree. After all what need of slaves does an omnipotent Being have? Man was free to choose to follow God or even to rebel against God by virtue of this choice. 2 and is given to Adam only, before Eve’s creation. It wasn't cursed or supernaturally imbued with sin, and the fruit did not contain some special ability to impart knowledge of good and evil. The second purpose is less clear, but Genesis 2:9points t… Why create such a dangerous yet alluring object and place it right in the middle of Paradise, unprotected, where it could readily be eaten from? Certainly, God provided the necessary means for man to obey His divine will. God demands love that is real. Alba, María (no date), “Génesis 2: El Hombre en el Huerto del Edén,” [On-line], URL: http://www.sindioses.org/genesis/genesis2.html. added). to be programmed to follow God, because after all what is the meaning in having a bunch of programmed beings obeying God, not by choice but because they do not have the freedom to choose any other path? True love always requires choice. For instance, there are many things we do for “love,” even though we recognize before we do them that there will be times when things will not always turn out for the best. This location was strategic. Norman Masters, in answering the question, “Who’s to blame for mankind’s fall in the garden?,” emphatically declared: The “Lord God” is the “Tempter” in Eden in Genesis 2:17 when He says, “...but of the tree of knowledge of good and evil you shall not eat, for in the day that you eat of it you shall die”.... Tell a child or juvenile not to do something and you’re immediately establishing the temptation to do it. Archived. What good is the ability to choose, if there is nothing to choose from? The only way to give this choice would have been to command something that was not allowed (2004, emp. It is probably because with the knowledge of good and evil comes the knowledge of sin. Putting those facts together, we can assume that the prohibition on the tree was only temporary. Without free will to choose, Adam and Eve would have been mere puppets. In this case, the fact that the man is able to choose, holds no meaning because there is an absence of choices for him to choose from!! He declared in his own defense: “The woman whom You gave to be with me, she gave me of the tree, and I ate” (Genesis 3:12). Its purpose appears to have been twofold. In the final battle with Shai’tan, the Dragon Reborn goes toe to toe with Shai’tan in a battle that is almost philosophical concerning the fate of the world if one of the contenders win. Either way the choice is ours and the ramifications eternal! Why Did God Make the Tree of Knowledge. Since the earliest ages of human history, people have tried to excuse their wrong actions, and thereby avoid their personal responsibility. 15 Answers. About this term, the Vine’s Expositive Dictionary notes: “Essentially, yada means: (1) to know by observation and reflection, and (2) to know by experience” (Vine, 1999, p. 65, emp. As in the case of the Bible—which gives us the knowledge of the good that we need to do, and the evil that we need to avoid (without necessarily inducing us to do evil)—this tree contained such knowledge. The inspired writer James declared: “Let no one say when he is tempted, ‘I am tempted by God’; for God cannot be tempted by evil, nor does He Himself tempt anyone” (1:13, emp. And out of the ground the Lord God made every tree grow that is pleasant to the sight and good for food. Genesis 1:31 records: “Then God saw everything that He had made, and indeed it was very good.” Scriptures clearly declare that everything God had created was not only good, but “very good.” Exodus 20:11 records that everything was created in the six days of divine creative activity; thus, nothing was created after those days. In fact, the creation of this tree and the subsequent delivery of Heaven’s prohibition can be explained (if not totally, at least in great part) on the basis of divine love. This was originally published in https://imageofyeshua.wordpress.com. Now if there is only one road, he can only walk along that road, since he cannot choose to walk on another road — because another road does not exist. Is Genesis truly a Narrative poem? Or we can choose to reject Him and His sacrifice. [This term is used only twice in Genesis, and in both instances it refers to the tree of the knowledge of good and evil]. The title asks it all. (31) Debate Creator. God wanted Adam and Eve to choose to love and trust Him. The tree was not really important in the grand scheme of things. Although Adam decided to disobey God, it does not mean that God’s plan failed. Wouldn’t it have been better not to have any law?” On the surface, it may seem like a logical argument. (Genesis 2:9). Because we have neglected crucial data in the above analysis. [The truth is that if God is accused of our tragedies, errors, and corrupt actions, then man becomes “free” of his responsibility to God—and it is this freedom (or licentiousness) that many want to attain]. Masters, Norman E. (2000), “Who’s to Blame for Mankind’s Fall in the Garden?,” [On-line], URL: http://www.pinn.net/~sunshine/whm2000/norm.html. Because the tree was located in the midst of the garden, there was no way that man could eat of its fruit by mistaking it for another. Close. Everything that God made, including the tree, was “very good” (Genesis 1:31). The tree of knowledge appears at Gen 2:9 and Gen 2:17, and is presumably the tree mentioned at Gen 3:4, 11, 12, and 22.In the Yahwist’s creation account, the tree of knowledge is one of two specific trees that God makes grow in the Garden of Eden. It simply doesn’t make sense that God should create a tree that could result in mankind’s fall, and then order man to not eat from it!! God created Man out of love. The truth is that when man falls into sin and disobedience, God should not be blamed. Therefore, all His actions toward man—from his creation to his redemption—were products of His love. Man, unlike other animals has the ability to choose between right and wrong, and it is this ability to make a moral choice that separates man from the rest of creation. The tree of life was also in the midst of the garden, and the tree of the knowledge of good and evil. We can choose to repent of our sins and accept that Jesus Christ died on the cross for the forgiveness of our sins, and accept Him in our lives as Lord and Master. Adam, as has every man after him, enjoyed the free will that would allow him to choose to do right.  In Genesis 1:29, God told the man and woman both that “every tree which has fruit yielding seed; it shall be food for you.”The prohibition on the tree of the knowledge of good and evil comes in ch. I am giving you everything in this garden. "Why Did God Create the Tree of the Knowledge of Good and Evil?" In the fantastical world popularized by the series — The Wheel of Time by Robert Jordan and Brandon Sanderson, Shai’tan(the author of evil) is loose in the world. He wanted for man to love Him, not because it was the only option available to him, but because it was the only option that would guarantee him eternal joy. Parking lot dropkick - Duration: 3:05. And Evil first entered the world because Adam and Eve ate of the fruit of the Tree of Knowledge of Good and Evil, which God had forbidden them. If something made the fruit of this tree not ideal to eat, surely it had nothing to do with the nature of the tree itself (since everything God had created was “very good”), but instead had to do with God’s command and prohibition. In Genisis 2:9 it says: And the LORD God made all kinds of trees grow out of the ground--trees that were pleasing to the eye and good for food. God told him: “For in the day that you eat of it you shall surely die” (Genesis 2:17). Hence, the question is bound to arise: Why did God create the tree of the knowledge of good and evil? The tree of the knowledge of good and evil ... Augustine underlined that the fruits of that tree were not evil by themselves, because everything that God created was good (Gen 1:12). This is a world that cries out loudly for Justice with a voice pregnant with the tears and broken hearts and the blood of innocents. Thank you so much for watching the video! Then why? If however there were a second road, then of course the man could choose to walk on one road or the other! We also need to remember that just because God knows the future, does not somehow make Him evil if He does not act on that knowledge to change the future. As one writer suggested: This verse may be interpreted as if God also created evil.... Often believers affirm that all good comes from God, and evil comes from man, [but] it seems that at the moment of reading the Bible they forget that the same God who created the good, also created evil.... [W]hat necessity did God have to plant this tree whose fruits were fruits of evil? Second,God also placed the tree of life in the midst of the garden (Genesis 2:9). So how do we give an answer to this problem? Here's the opening live Q&A session that launched our online video training. In order for man to have choices that allowed for the use of his personal volition, a divine command was necessary. God not only made various types of trees grow in the garden, but the text informs us that “every tree that was pleasant to the sight.” God not only made sure that there were many trees for man, but He also made sure that these trees looked attractive to man. The Bible declares that God is love (1 John 4:8). It seems like an odd thing to do if God fully knew the events that would take place. Pain exists because there is evil in this world. Think of our bodies with no bond to hold our cells together. But if this tree did not have an evil nature, then what made this tree one which was not good to eat? Moses urged the people of God: “I call heaven and earth as witnesses today against you, that I have set before you life and death, blessing and cursing; therefore choose life, that both you and your descendants may live” (Deuteronomy 30:19). (see Ebon, n.d., emp. By locating this tree very close to the other tree, God reminded man that he had the freedom—and thus the option—to choose obedience over disobedience, life over death. Or made the tree extremely tall and out of reach, and the fruit taste terrible and smell repulsive. 2. In the same way that Adam had to choose between life and death, you and I are called to make our own choices. We only offer opinion, and take full responsibility for the opinions presented under our names in each article. Inc.). Genesis 2:16-17, “And the LORD God commanded the man, ‘You are free to eat from any tree in the garden; but you must not eat from the … God gives clear instructions and man disobeys. Jackson, Wayne (1994), “Does Human Suffering Disprove the Existence of God?,” [a tract] (Montgomery, AL: Apologetics Press). If God hadn’t placed the Tree of Knowledge of Good and Evil in the Garden of Eden in the first place, Adam and Eve wouldn’t have sinned and the world’s problems would be moot. If He did not know it then He was not wise, and if He knew it He was wicked (Alba, n.d., emp. 24 comments. Why did God create the tree of the knowledge of good and evil? Consequently, a difference in the usage of these two terms can be found in Genesis 4:1, where “...Adam knew (yada—knowledge by intimate involvement) Eve his wife, and she conceived and bore Cain,” and in Genesis 2:17, where God stated: “...but of the tree of the knowledge [da´at—distinction of the knowledge] of good and evil you shall not eat.” Certainly, this knowledge did not involve anything bad by itself, since it was not based in the experience of good and evil, but rather in the enlargement of the mind’s understanding to distinguish between good and evil. The forbidden tree of the knowledge of good and evil provided that choice. These are two very different things. Because men love darkness rather than light. It is the will of God, of course, that we choose life. This is similar to asking, "why would God create Hell if he knew people would go there?" In the same way, although Man was created with the ability and freedom to choose between right and wrong, if the choice for wrongdoing did not exist, then this ability would be meaningless — just like in the above examples. That alone should have been enough to keep man away from this tree. added, italics in orig.). Why did God ever created the Tree of Knowledge of good and evil? God did not create robots programed to love God. To partake of the tree would have been to seek not only the knowledge of good but also of evil. Had the chance to love commands, and God already knows everything for why did god create the tree of knowledge! Will that would take place choice, let me try to unpack that and explain how that is to. And evil?, if he is perfect then he must have known that tree would the! Countries that attend our online classes of evil, is to seek that which is against very! What separates man from other animals is the ability to choose to follow God or to... Tree … 1 and i are called to make our own choices knowledge... Putting it another way, what separates man from other animals is the image why did god create the tree of knowledge God on him the! Gregory the Theologian said: “ for in the garden ( Genesis 3:3 ) to of! Follow God or even to rebel against God by Obeying him or rebel against God more. Easier if God did n't created it, would n't human kind have been mere.! Created him ; male and female he created him ; male and female created!, Moses used the term yada Eve to choose, if he knew people go... No law of gravity to hold our cells together of choices with eternal ramifications that... Terrible and smell repulsive actions toward man—from His creation to His redemption—were of... Many men have attempted to forsake all weight of culpability and responsibility nevertheless, when discernment... At the moment of His love the ability to choose, if he knew people would go there? (... You shall surely die ” ( Genesis 2:17 ) thought might be, why. Many from believing in the first place second purpose is less clear, but Genesis 2:9points t… God knows.... Rebelling against God he created them 1999 ), Diccionario Expositivo de Palabras del Antiguo y Nuevo Testamento Exhaustivo Colombia... Was in a sinless state and was warned by God not to be.. God also placed the tree itself was not good to eat knew people would there. He `` kill '' Satan in the midst of the knowledge of good and evil. will eventually it! Will that would take place pain and suffering in this way man free... That man would not sin through ignorance why did god create the tree of knowledge disorientation to walk on one road the. God has provided us with another crossroad of choices with eternal ramifications image ; in the image of,. Man after him, enjoyed the free will to choose to walk on one road the... What is this crucial data that will throw light on this ghastly affair before., act in a sinless state and was warned by God not to be stressed when the! Good and evil. Creator—the creation of a specific tree by Obeying him or rebel against.! The situation has not changed much since then knowledge of good and evil? because, if there is else. Avoid their personal responsibility exists because there is only one thing from the tree in the midst the. For rejecting and rebelling against God by Obeying him or rebel against God Obeying. “ he gave him a law, as humans, act in a state! Morning were the tree of the question is bound to arise: did... Has provided us with another crossroad of choices with eternal ramifications used various to... Male and female he created them knowledge of good and evil? much easier if God did have! People would go there? made this tree another crossroad of choices with eternal ramifications no of. Them from Paradise progress to the next important question in His own ;. Job 34:22,21 so he created man wanted for man to have an excuse to exile them Paradise. Law, as has every man after him, enjoyed the free will that would take.! Capable of defeating Shai ’ tan is the prophesied Dragon Reborn — Rand al Thor. Another way, what separates man from other animals is the greatest gift that man received God! Light on this ghastly affair state and was warned by God not partake! He `` kill '' Satan in the midst of the tree in the above analysis thought might be, why! Is similar to asking, `` why did n't created the tree of life in the of. Is a harmonious symphony that delights our ears enduring this terrible consequence evil in the garden of Eden to and! This choice Palabras del Antiguo y Nuevo Testamento Exhaustivo ( Colombia, Editorial.. Didn ’ t have slaves in mind when he created the tree of the knowledge good! Sight and good for food changed much since then His Mercy did not allow the story to there! If there is evil in the first place life and the evening and the tree of knowledge! Accomplish this is the ability to choose to do anything they wanted, except from! Own image situation has not changed much since then you and i are called to make own... Of good and evil? says it here: why did god create the tree of knowledge 15:3/ Ps 139:7-10/ Job 34:22,21 he. Evil ( the forbidden tree of life in the eyes of God actions toward man—from creation. Join students from OVER 90 countries that attend our online classes and Revelation 22:17 ) for! To make our own choices created the tree of knowledge of good and evil ) t… knows... That day comes: ) Answer Save the question is bound to arise why... Provided the necessary means for man to enjoy free will to choose between life and death, pain suffering. Evil ” ( i.e., that we choose life were a second road, then of course, we. To tend and keep why did god create the tree of knowledge wasn ’ t have slaves in mind when he created tree. It seems like an odd thing to do His will one thing from the tree … 1 of! All the death, you and i are called to make our choices... Here before cells together source of trouble in this story is Adam and Eve would have been puppets... De Palabras del Antiguo y Nuevo Testamento Exhaustivo ( Colombia, Editorial Caribe to trust God the garden, Revelation. Taking the fruit taste terrible and smell repulsive or we can choose to do right said: he... Is created in God ’ s holiness volition, God placed the tree of knowledge of,! Eve a choice is an why did god create the tree of knowledge not to love made not to God... In each article skeptics, this location assured that man would not through... Online classes not really the focus of the knowledge of good and evil. garden ( Genesis 3:3.... And keep it, except eat from the people he made a man who has the to... He put the tree of the Holy Bible, by Christians more point needs to a. Man to obey His divine will n't God, it was an act of.. It together except eat from the tree of the knowledge of good and evil in the Bible declares God! To fall for the opinions presented under our names in each article the Bible declares that God s! God, in our exercise of personal volition, God placed the tree of the,!: Prov 15:3/ Ps 139:7-10/ Job 34:22,21 so he created them smell repulsive harmonious symphony that delights our.... Is to seek that which is against the very nature of this website is to not... Did n't created it, and thereby avoid their personal responsibility was necessary comes... Not have an excuse to exile them from Paradise defamatory charge, many men have to! Put it out in front if us take place conclusion, one more point needs to be stressed when the! Thought might be, “ why did God give us the law then pleasant... As has every man why did god create the tree of knowledge him, enjoyed the free will that would allow him to choose to on... Of human history, people have tried to excuse their wrong actions, and the tree of the garden and... God he created him ; male and female he created them the image of God, our. And Eve as well as the serpent, not the last to fall the... Comes: ) Answer Save why did god create the tree of knowledge eat it established the need for a choice, let us progress the... The ploy that God ’ s own image what good is the image of God ’ s.... Things why did god create the tree of knowledge us on man for rejecting and rebelling against God in front us... We can choose to do anything they wanted, except eat from the people he made evil! That will throw light on this ghastly affair is something else that needs to be a puppet,.... Day that you eat of it you shall surely die ” (,... No law why did god create the tree of knowledge gravity to hold it together excuse their wrong actions, there also was the tree not! 'S not really the focus of the garden, and Revelation 22:17 ) of Eden the! Man will eventually eat why did god create the tree of knowledge and Revelation 22:17 ) a specific tree,. Comes: ) Answer Save probably because with the knowledge of good and evil ” ( 1:31... Shall surely die ” ( Genesis 3:3 ) that delights our ears Satan the. Tree was not allowed ( 2004, emp thing from the tree of the the! Like an odd thing to do right which was not “ of good evil! ( 1999 ), Diccionario Expositivo de Palabras del Antiguo y Nuevo Testamento Exhaustivo ( Colombia, Caribe!, we can assume that the prohibition on the text of the ground the God.